Executive Search

The technology leader your plan needs has already done it somewhere else.

Retained, confidential search for CTOs, CISOs, CPOs, VPs of Engineering and data and AI leaders at PE-backed and founder-led SaaS and payments companies. Our CEO, Elizabeth DeFazio, runs every search, and every finalist goes through a live technical review with our Technical COO and partner engineers before you meet them: the platform they rebuilt, the migration or audit they delivered, and the team they grew.

  • 87 daysFrom intake to a CTO’s start date, after the client’s front-runner withdrew at offer.
  • 17 daysFrom our first submittal to a signed VP of Product at a payments platform.
  • 15 daysFrom submittal to signed hire, on average, across our technology searches.

Every executive search in the last two years was filled, with no restart.

Anew Recruit records, executive searches completed 2024–2026. Ranges, not guarantees. Our figures run to the accepted offer; the start date follows once the new leader has served the notice owed to their current employer.

Led by our CEO

Your search is led by our CEO, not handed down.

At many search firms, the partner who wins the work hands the search to a team you rarely meet. At Anew Recruit, Elizabeth DeFazio leads every executive search herself: the intake with your CEO and investors, the calibration slate, and the final recommendation. She takes on a limited number of searches at a time, so yours gets her attention.

Elizabeth DeFazio and her firm “have been able to recruit top engineering and product talent for me.”

The CTO placed at a PE-backed sports-management SaaS platform
Roles

Technology leaders we recruit

Retained search for the technology organization, from the CTO down.

  • Chief Technology Officer

    A re-platforming, a buy-and-build, or the technical diligence a buyer will run at exit.

  • Chief Information Security Officer

    SOC 2, PCI or an enterprise customer wants one accountable owner.

  • Chief Product Officer / VP of Product

    A roadmap the board can see turning into growth.

  • VP of Engineering

    Delivery has slipped, or the team has outgrown its structure.

  • CIO / Head of IT and Business Systems

    A carve-out, an integration, or the ERP behind the add-ons.

  • Head of Data and AI

    Models in production, and data the board trusts.

  • Head of Platform and Infrastructure

    Cloud spend, uptime commitments and one platform after the add-ons.

When to call us

When CEOs and sponsors call us

Most technology searches start with a business event, not a vacancy. We recruit for the event.

  • After the deal closes

    A CTO for the next stage

    The founder-era CTO built version one. The value-creation plan needs someone who has scaled a platform, a team and a budget to the next stage.

  • Legacy modernization

    Modernize without a rewrite

    A .NET Framework monolith or an aging stack has to become modern and cloud-native while customers keep using it. You need a CTO who has done it in increments, not a big-bang rewrite.

  • Buy-and-build

    One platform, not four

    A CTO who has moved acquired products onto shared services, one identity layer and one data model, and can tell you what it cost.

  • AI in the product

    A CTO who has shipped it

    The board wants AI features customers will pay for. You need a CTO who has put AI into production with evaluation, guardrails and a cost per request the CFO can see, not a demo.

  • Delivery has stalled

    Speed and quality, measured

    Releases slip and bugs reach customers. A CTO who runs engineering on cycle time, deployment frequency and escaped defects, and fixes the system rather than blaming the team.

  • Exit on the horizon

    Ready for technical diligence

    Buyers will examine the architecture, scalability, security, IP and technical debt. A CTO who has been through diligence before and knows what a clean data room looks like.

Why searches succeed

Executive hires rarely fail on the resume. They fail on fit with the plan, the people and the board.

Research on C-suite transitions published by the Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance finds the same risks behind failed executive hires: culture, trust with peers and the relationship with the board, in the first 12 to 18 months. So we design the search around those risks from day one. Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance, 2025

CISOs are increasingly a CEO-level hire: 42% now report directly to the CEO, three times the share in the previous year’s survey. Heidrick & Struggles, 2025 Global CISO Compensation Survey

  • A brief nobody agreed on

    Mandate before market

    We turn the business plan into a success profile and a weighted scorecard that your CEO, hiring executive and investors sign off before anyone is approached.

  • Polished claims, thin evidence

    Evidence, not adjectives

    Every submittal is scored against that scorecard and separates what a candidate told us from what we have confirmed, with the questions worth your interview time.

  • The wrong fit with people and board

    Every stakeholder in the loop

    We plan the interview path the hire must win, from the hiring executive to the sponsor and the board, and stay close through the first 90 days.

Assessment

Every finalist is tested by engineers before you meet them.

A senior title says little about what someone has built. Our Technical COO and partner engineers test the architecture and how delivery is measured, we test what your plan needs, and your technical leaders test the depth.

  • Your situation, not a case study

    Finalists talk through how they would approach your platform, your team and your plan.

  • Stage fit, with evidence

    The team size when they arrived and when they left, the stage and ownership model, and what they rebuilt, consolidated or shut down.

  • Commercial fluency

    Budget, cloud and vendor spend, and how they report to a board and a sponsor.

  • Confirmed, not claimed

    Each finalist report separates what the candidate told us from what we have confirmed, with references at the agreed stage.

  • Inheriting work in flight

    Most new technology leaders take over a modernization or integration someone else started. Finalists tell us what they would keep, pause or reverse in the first 90 days, and why.

  • Architecture judgment

    Finalists walk through an architecture they designed or inherited: domain boundaries, event-driven or modular-monolith choices, what they made reusable, and which pattern they would not use again.

  • Delivery, measured

    How they know engineering is healthy: cycle time, deployment frequency, change failure rate and time to restore, and what they changed the last time the numbers were bad.

  • AI, in the product and the team

    Where AI runs in their product, how it is evaluated and what it costs, and how their engineers use AI coding and review tools without lowering the bar on testing and security.

  • Your technical leaders run the deep interview

    Your CTO, architects or a technical adviser test the depth. We give them the gaps worth testing and the questions to ask.

The search

Six phases. A deliverable at every one.

Every week: a written update and a standing call covering activity, the pipeline, market feedback and the decisions we need from you.

  1. 01MandateDays 1–3

    In the first three days we meet your CEO, the hiring executive and, where relevant, your investors. Together we define what this leader must deliver in their first 12 to 24 months in the role, and the pay and equity you can offer to win them. Nothing goes to market until you sign it.

    You receive

    • Intake notes within 24 hours
    • Position specification and success profile
    • Weighted scorecard you can edit
    • Compensation and equity framework, benchmarked and approved by your board or sponsor before outreach
    • Off-limits list agreed in writing
    • A standing weekly call
  2. 02Market mapWeeks 1–2

    We map the companies, teams and leaders most likely to have done this work, including strong people we have met on earlier searches.

    You receive

    • Target-company map
    • Calibration call on early profiles
  3. 03Calibration slateWeeks 2–3

    The first candidates, most of them not looking. As your interviews start, every round of feedback is built back into the scorecard: what predicts success in your seat gets more weight, what turned out to be noise gets less. Candidates already in the process are re-scored, and everyone who follows is measured against the sharper scorecard, so each slate gets closer to the signal.

    You receive

    • Written submittals: relevance, scorecard, motivation, status
    • Questions for your interviewers
    • A scorecard update after each feedback round, with candidates re-scored against it
  4. 04AssessmentWeeks 3–6

    We study each candidate’s career before we meet and build targeted questions around the results they claim. Candidates walk us through each story step by step: where things stood, what they decided, who was involved, what changed, and the numbers before and after. Each answer earns a sharper follow-up question until the evidence is clear. Every finalist has a live conversation with us, and key facts are checked before anything reaches you. Optional: a validated leadership assessment for finalists, debriefed by a certified practitioner, to sharpen your final interviews.

    You receive

    • An evidence report on each finalist: their key stories, the figures behind them, and what is confirmed versus self-reported
    • Finalist comparison against the scorecard
    • The gaps worth testing in your final interviews, with suggested questions
    • References at the agreed stage, with permission
  5. 05OfferWeeks 5–10

    Because the package was agreed at the start, the offer is about fit, not surprises. We learn what will decide the candidate’s yes, from scope and equity to family and relocation, and build the close around it. We test motivation and counteroffer risk, explain the equity in plain terms, check notice periods and any restrictive covenants early so the start date is realistic, and keep a second finalist warm until the contract is signed.

    You receive

    • Final offer recommendation within the approved framework
    • The candidate’s decision drivers and a close plan
    • Counteroffer and resignation plan
    • Notice and start-date plan, with any non-compete or non-solicit flagged for your counsel
    • A backup finalist until signature
    • A contact plan for the notice period, so your hire stays engaged before day one
  6. 06IntegrationFirst 90 days

    The assessment does not end at signature. We hand you what we learned so the new leader starts on their strengths, then check in with you and with them separately as they settle, so culture, peer and board issues surface early, while they are easy to fix.

    You receive

    • Onboarding brief: strengths to use, gaps to support, and the stakeholders to win first
    • First-90-day priorities agreed with the hiring executive
    • Separate check-ins with you and the new leader at 30, 60 and 90 days
    • Support hiring the new leader’s own team
    • Cover under your replacement guarantee
Private equity and founders

Built for PE-backed and founder-led companies

Portfolio companies that appointed a new CEO in the first year of the hold exited after 4.4 years on average, against 7.7 years when the appointment came after year two.

Russell Reynolds Associates, “The CEO Decision,” August 2026

Leadership timing and the value-creation plan move together. We plan the search around both.

  • Hired against the value-creation plan

    The scorecard starts from what the sponsor underwrote: the platform, the integrations and the diligence ahead.

  • Operating partners in the loop

    Your sponsor’s technology or operating partner joins the interview path where it adds the most.

  • Already in the loop

    When a client’s front-runner for CTO withdrew at offer, our candidate was already in the process and won the board’s consensus.

  • The team under the leader

    After we placed one sponsor-backed company’s CTO, he hired his engineering and product team through us.

Proof

Executive case studies

Technology leaders we have placed. Client names are withheld; each card names the segment.

  • Chief Technology Officer

    Building-services contractor SaaS · PE-backed · Omaha, NE (remote role) · Direct-hire search

    Hiring need
    A PE-backed SaaS company growing by acquisition needed a CTO who had done it before.
    Result
    The front-runner withdrew at offer; Anew’s candidate was already in the process and won the board’s consensus.
    The CTO

    “My first 6 months … has been great.”

    Hiring need
    A PE-backed SaaS company growing by acquisition needed a CTO who had done the job before on an M&A path: to build “a cohesive technical and product vision” and connect acquisitions along the way.
    Result
    When the client’s front-runner withdrew at offer stage, Anew’s candidate was already in the process. After a loop that included the chief executive and an outside board member, the client reported “the consensus was strong”, and the new CTO started 87 days after intake.
    The CTO, six months in

    “My first 6 months … has been great.”

    Learn more about the Chief Technology Officer case study (Building-services contractor SaaS)
  • Chief Technology Officer

    Sports-management SaaS platform · PE-backed · Frisco, TX · Monthly retainer plus direct-hire placements

    Hiring need
    A PE-backed sports-management SaaS platform needed a CTO to scale its engineering and product teams.
    Result
    The CTO Anew placed went on to build his engineering and product team with Anew.
    The CTO

    “…able to recruit top engineering and product talent for me.”

    Hiring need
    A sports-management SaaS platform taking on a new private-equity investor needed a CTO to scale its engineering and product teams.
    Result
    Anew placed the CTO and became his hiring partner, feeding the engineering and product build-out directly to him, from software developers and architects to a VP of Engineering. A year on, he came back for more: “Are you able to still help us with open tech roles?”
    The CTO

    Elizabeth DeFazio and her firm “have been able to recruit top engineering and product talent for me.”

    Learn more about the Chief Technology Officer case study (Sports-management SaaS platform)
  • VP of Product

    Embedded-payments FinTech platform · Investor-backed · United States · Executive search

    Hiring need
    An investor-backed FinTech platform needed a VP to lead its product function.
    Result
    Signed 17 days after Anew’s first submittal, after meetings with the hiring executives and the C-suite.
    Hiring need
    An investor-backed payments-facilitation platform needed a VP to lead its product function, with its senior leadership team in the selection.
    Result
    The eventual hire met the hiring executives and the C-suite and signed 17 days after Anew’s first submittal.
    Learn more about the VP of Product case study (Embedded-payments FinTech platform)
Client experience

What technology leaders say

“I had to build an entire tech hub in a new city with a new company and I went to Anew Recruit because they deliver. We are a very intense tech shop, too. They placed one of our best leaders on the team in addition to many more.”

Martin L.CPO & CTO, Sports-betting technology company

“We needed a Vice President of Product for our payments company and Anew Recruit came through! They identified outstanding talent and we were able to choose someone who checked every box. We are planning to use them again for more executive level and tech searches as we continue to grow.”

Bob B.PE-backed SaaS payments company
AI-assisted, human-led

The research depth of a large firm. The attention of a boutique.

Cookie, our AI research assistant, gives a small senior team the reach of a much larger one. Recruiters stay accountable for every judgment.

  • Remembers every search

    Briefs, scorecards, calibration feedback and market insight are kept, so your search starts ahead, not from a blank page.

  • Maps the market by meaning

    It searches our database and the wider market by experience, not just titles, and finds leaders we have met before.

  • Compares consistently

    Every profile is compared with the scorecard you agreed, so a broad market narrows quickly to the people worth a conversation.

  • Drafts, never decides

    It drafts notes and summaries that a recruiter checks, corrects and signs off before you see them.

AI never decides who is rejected, ranked or introduced, never interviews a candidate, and never sees more of your confidential information than the search needs. How we use AI

Integrity

Confidential, careful and verified

  • Confidential by design

    Leadership changes are sensitive. We agree what can be shared, with whom and when, before outreach begins.

  • Off-limits respected

    You give us the companies and people we must not approach, and the list is agreed in writing.

  • Real people, real records

    Gartner expects one in four candidate profiles to be fake by 2028. Every finalist has a live conversation with our recruiters, and key facts are confirmed at the agreed stage.

Fraud forecast: Gartner, reported by HR Dive, August 2025

Questions CEOs and boards ask about technology leaders

Who assesses a CTO’s technical depth?

Our Technical COO and partner engineers run a live technical review of every finalist: the architecture they designed or inherited, how they measure delivery, and how AI runs in their product and their team. We also test what the plan needs: stage fit, delivery record, commercial fluency and how they lead engineers, and we separate what a candidate told us from what we have confirmed. Your board, CTO or technical adviser can still run their own deep interview, with the gaps worth testing from our finalist report.

CTO or VP of Engineering: which do we need?

A CTO faces outward: technology strategy, the board, investors and a buyer’s technical diligence. A VP of Engineering faces inward: delivery, team structure and retention. PE-backed companies often need a CTO for a buy-and-build or re-platforming plan, and a VP of Engineering when delivery has slipped or the team has outgrown its structure. Agreeing which one you need is the first part of the search.

Can you find a leader to take over a migration already under way?

Yes. For a newly acquired SaaS company we replaced a retiring engineering lead while a legacy .NET Framework codebase was being modernized to current .NET on AWS. The client’s CTO tested domain-driven design, event sourcing and CQRS, and how each finalist would modernize in increments without stopping delivery. Intake to accepted offer took about five weeks.

Have you placed CTOs at PE-backed software companies?

Yes. Recent CTO placements include a building-services SaaS company growing by acquisition, where our candidate won the board’s consensus, and a sports-management SaaS platform taking on a new private-equity investor, where the CTO then built his engineering team through us, from developers and architects to a VP of Engineering. We have placed CTOs at two portfolio companies of the same software-focused private equity firm.

How do you assess a CTO’s AI experience?

We ask what is actually in production: which AI features customers use, how they are evaluated, what each request costs and how customer data is protected. We also ask how their engineers use AI coding and code-review tools, and what review and testing keep that code safe to ship. Demos and roadmaps don’t count.

How long does a technology executive search take?

In our executive searches completed in 2024–2026, the first candidates arrived 11 to 18 days after intake, and kickoff to an accepted offer took five to ten weeks. A VP of Product signed 17 days after our first submittal. Your interview availability is the biggest variable, so we agree it at kickoff.

Can you replace a technology leader confidentially?

Yes. We have run confidential replacement searches for PE-backed companies with the incumbent still in the seat. We keep your company unnamed until the right moment, limit who sees what, and keep outreach and paperwork off the radar until the new leader signs.

Do you advise on compensation and equity?

Yes. Before outreach we benchmark the compensation and equity framework, and your board or sponsor approves it, so the offer is about fit rather than surprises.

What if the hire doesn’t work out?

Every executive search is backed by a 90-day replacement guarantee, and extended plans cover 180 days or more. The terms are set out in writing before the search begins.

How are fees structured?

Leadership searches are retained, with the first installment at kickoff. Fees and the payment schedule are confirmed in writing before work begins.

Can you hire the team under the new leader?

Yes. After we placed one PE-backed SaaS company’s CTO, he hired his engineering and product team through us, and contract specialists can cover the gap while the permanent team is recruited.

The 180-Day Leadership Guarantee

Every executive search is backed for 90 days. Extended plans cover 180 days or more.

Ask us how it works. Terms in writing.

Book a time

Start with a confidential conversation.

Tell us about the plan, the leadership gap and your timing. We confirm scope, confidentiality and terms in writing before any search begins.

What happens next

  1. Share a few details. Six short fields about you and your company.
  2. Choose a time. Pick a slot on our calendar for a conversation with Anew Recruit.
  3. Talk through the search. We discuss the roles, priorities, and timing, then confirm scope and terms in writing before any search starts.

Tell us about your company.

Step 1 of 2: share your details. Step 2: choose a time on our calendar. All fields are required.

Prefer email? Write to info@anewrecruit.com. Looking for a job? Visit For Candidates so your application reaches the right place. See our privacy notice.